You’re turning me into a paranoid lunatic again, tories.

BBC News – MP Graham Allen calls for early years intervention.

This is going to take some unpacking, but let’s start with the pull quote:

 

Graham Allen, Labour MP for Nottingham North

“Socially and emotionally capable people are more productive, better educated, tax-paying citizens helping our nation to compete in the global economy, and make fewer demands on public expenditure”

Graham Allen MP and report author

You know what, I have no quarrel with the essential truth of this: fair enough, it’s a psychotic method of treating your population, as production units in the global economy, but it’s all true.

The problem I have is this: what evidence do we have that the current state education system produces “socially and emotionally capable people”?

A revolting phrase in this debate has surfaced, referring to placing 4 year olds in formal classrooms: “insufficiently institutionalised”.

Presumably, then, the aim of school (and under this proposal, pre-school), is to produce young adults who are “sufficiently institutionalised”.

Dependent. Biddable. Knowing their place.

In fact, almost exactly the opposite of “Socially and emotionally capable people.”

This crop of politicians seems to be suffering from the same delusion as the last lot as regards school: “School is not working. The answer is more school.”

Personally, I don’t think institutionalisation is an inevitable consequence of schooling, but it is an emergent property, a tendency that should, in a just world, be guarded against.

Instead, it seems to be being embraced by the very people that are extolling its opposite in a bid to extend school from the moment of conception, if not before.

I am proud of raising children who are insufficiently institutionalised: if there is one glaring problem with my own life, it is that I am sufficiently institutionalised, and insufficiently socially and emotionally capable.

I went to a selective grammar school and was the first member of my family to gain a university degree.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “You’re turning me into a paranoid lunatic again, tories.

  1. THIS NOT A REPLY. An APPRECIATION! I SEARCHED FOR YOU PETE after I HEARD YOU READ BOOK 10 OF THE ILIAD VIA LIBERVOX..AND NEVER HAD THIS MARVELLOUS WORK GOTTEN TO ME AS WITH YOUR FIERCE READING..THANK YOU SO MUCH. I PRESUMED YOU WERE AN ACTOR.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s